A long, quiet barrier island where club life, boating, and Gulf-front living set the pace.
Longboat Key stretches for miles between Sarasota Bay and the Gulf, spanning two counties along the way. It is noticeably calmer than the islands to the south, and that is precisely why people choose it. There is no crowded village here. The island is largely residential, organized around beach access, golf, tennis, and the water.
What you trade in nightlife you gain in space and quiet. St. Armands and downtown Sarasota are a drive down the key rather than a walk, which suits residents who want their island to feel like a retreat.
Tell Rich what you are looking for and he will give you a straight answer, even if the answer is somewhere else.
Mornings here look like beach walks and bike rides down the key. Club life is a real part of the culture, with golf and tennis anchoring the social calendar for many residents, and the bay side drawing boaters who want quick access to open water.
It is an island that rewards routine. Residents tend to know their neighbors, and the rhythm is steady rather than seasonal in feel, even though season certainly brings more activity. For buyers coming from a busy metro, the quiet is usually the selling point.
Rich will show you around, in person or live over video if you are out of state.
The island offers a broad mix: Gulf-front condominium buildings with resort-style amenities, bayfront and canal homes with deep-water dockage, and gated neighborhoods that include club membership opportunities. Estates on the bay side are among the most sought-after properties in the region.
Because Longboat spans both Sarasota and Manatee counties, details like taxes, services, and even school assignment can differ depending on where on the key a property sits. That is exactly the kind of thing worth confirming before you commit, and something I walk clients through property by property.
Buyers who want a quieter, more private island setting
Boaters looking for deep-water access and dockage
Golf and tennis club members who want it all close to home
Seasonal residents wanting a low-key, low-maintenance base
Inventory moves quickly here. Rich will send you what is on the market and what is coming, before it hits the portals.
Generally yes. Longboat is largely residential and does not have a central village district the way Siesta does, so it tends to feel calmer and more private. Buyers who want walkable nightlife usually prefer Siesta or Lido, while those who want quiet gravitate to Longboat.
It is a strong choice. The bay side offers canal and bayfront properties with dockage, including deep-water options, and access to open water is a major reason many owners buy here. The right slip and draft depend on the specific property.
The island spans both Sarasota and Manatee counties, so the answer depends on where the property sits along the key. That split can affect taxes and services, so it is worth confirming for any specific address.
Ask Rich directly. No pressure and no script, just a real answer from someone who lives and works here.
Rich lives here, works here, and will give you a straight answer about whether this is the right fit.
Schedule a Consultation
Rich and his family are celebrating four years in Sarasota. His honest hit list: five things they love, two real negatives, and two tidbits for New Yorkers and parents, with the full story on video.
Read More →
Everything a New Yorker needs to know about moving to Sarasota: taxes, cost of living, the process, and how to buy from out of state.
Read More →
